Gluten Free or Gluten Fear?

What and where is gluten?

Gluten and related proteins are found in wheat, rye, barley, and possibly oats. The jury is still out on whether oat proteins, or proteins from other grains that contaminate oats are the main problem for those on a gluten free diet.

Thousands of foods contain these grains, which means that completely avoiding gluten is no small task. Pretty much, any processed food not specifically labeled gluten-free should be considered suspect.

Why the fear of gluten?

Celiac disease is a condition in which the immune system reacts to gluten and related proteins. For people with celiac disease (CD), there is no question that a 100% gluten free diet is absolutely necessary to maintain good health.

With CD, failure to avoid gluten can lead to very serious health problems, including thyroid disease, joint damage, neurological effects, alopecia (hair loss), skin rashes, intestinal cancer, and of course, damage to the intestinal tract. This can cause malabsorption of nutrients, leading to conditions such as osteoporosis and anemia.

In short, if you have celiac disease, avoiding gluten should be your number one diet priority.

Given that the number of people affected by celiac disease is on the rise, and the scary list of symptoms that can accompany it, it’s not surprising that fear of gluten is on the rise too. But there’s a catch.

Most of the people who have celiac disease (CD) don’t know it. And contrary to popular opinion, not everyone with CD has gastrointestinal symptoms. Only 35% of those with CD report experiencing diarrhea, for example.

Who is gluten free?

Numbers are hard to come by, but celiac disease experts believe that of the roughly 2 million Americans with CD, about 80% or 1.6 million don’t know they have it. Conversely, approximately 1.6 million people in the US without CD are believed to be following a gluten free diet.

Sadly, this means that many who need a gluten free diet aren’t on one, and many who are on a gluten free diet don’t need it. This is why I often refer to CD as the “simultaneously most under- and over-diagnosed” condition in the US.

For those who truly have CD, the time from onset of symptoms to diagnosis can be agonizingly long, up to 10 years for many adults. Yet, many people diagnose themselves with CD without any evidence that they have the condition.

Many of life’s common woes – fatigue, stress, anxiety, lack of energy, insomnia, weight gain – are attributed to gluten, despite a lack of evidence to support these claims.

Gluten intolerance without celiac disease

If you suspect you are sensitive to gluten, yet a blood test for celiac disease indicates you do not have the condition, you may have something called non-celiac gluten sensitivity. Undoubtedly, some people without celiac disease still don’t digest gluten very well. But as with celiac disease, it appears likely that many more people believe they have non-celiac gluten sensitivity than actually do.

As Dr. Stefano Guandalini, Director of the Celiac Disease Center at the University of Chicago recently told the NY Times, a gluten free diet, “is not a healthier diet for those who don’t need it,” and that many people are essentially “following a fad.” Dr. Guandalini hastened to add, “And that’s my biased opinion.”

Should you go gluten free?

You should consider going gluten free if you have reason to believe you have celiac disease. Why might you have CD?

If someone in your family has it, this increases the likelihood that you may develop the condition too. If you or anyone in your family has an autoimmune disease, especially type 1 diabetes, rheumatoid arthritis, autoimmune thyroid or liver disease, Addison’s disease, or Sjögren’s syndrome, this too can increase the odds of CD.

And to confirm your suspicions, ask your doctor for a blood test. There’s one caveat: Do not go gluten free before you get the blood test. Doing so can render the test completely inaccurate.

The gray area

What about non-celiac gluten intolerance? It is possible you’ll feel better without gluten in your diet, but for many people, feeling better results from cutting out junk food, not gluten. Going gluten free means far fewer baked goods, pretzels, chips, cookies, pies, and other nutrition bombs.

Simply paying better attention to what you put in your mouth, and eliminating most processed food will make anyone feel better, gain energy, and lose weight. You can accomplish this without nixing gluten… Not a bad idea, given that gluten free does not mean healthy. Many people end up eating a less-nutritious diet when cutting out gluten.

To avoid this pitfall, talk to a dietitian or doctor who specializes in gluten free diets to help you sort it out. With his or her help, you can do something called an elimination diet. Gluten can be one of those things you eliminate, and you can track your symptoms accordingly.

With professional help, you can apply the elimination approach to many potential dietary trouble spots, in a systematic fashion. You may just discover some other dietary culprit that is making you feel poorly. And given how difficult it is to completely avoid gluten, you’ll probably be glad to narrow down your issues to something else.

For everyone else?

Don’t give in to the fad.

As Dr. Alan Leichtner, MD, senior associate in medicine at Boston Children’s Hospital Division of Gastroenterology and Nutrition says, “There are no studies showing that the gluten-free diet has an impact on anything other than celiac disease. The medical data simply aren’t there.”


2 responses

  1. I’ve been looking for a blog like this for a long time now! I would say I wished I’d found you sooner but you just started so I’ll say… thank you! Good information. I’ve been trying to go mostly GF for a while now because I *think* it’s not good for me, but I’ve had a negative celiac test and blood reaction test also showed no reaction to gluten. THe only thing I know for sure is when I cut out grains my rosacea went away, but that also could have been any number of other things besides the gluten. I’m in the process of wrapping my head around this whole thing… wish there was more conclusive (and non-biased) info in general.

    • Thank you for the great feedback Bethany! I really believe that there are two sides to this coin. 1. Gluten free is a fad. 2. However, celiac disease and non-celiac gluten sensitivity do seem to be increasing. Given these two things, I encourage people to figure out for themselves whether going gluten free really helps their health. It’s not an easy thing to be 100% gluten free. Ask anyone with celiac disease, for whom being 100% gluten free is, literally, a life saver, and they’ll tell you how challenging it is to completely avoid gluten. If a person doesn’t need to do it for health, I would never encourage him or her to follow a gluten-free diet. Beyond the issue of gluten, we need to consider food allergies too. People can be allergic to wheat, but have no problem with gluten itself. If this is the case, avoiding wheat should improve health, but a person could still enjoy barley, rye, and oats, which are great sources of nutrients and fiber. In the end, if you’ve figured out an approach for improving your health that works for you, you’re on the right track, with or without gluten. One interesting thing about rosacea, and you may already know this: The condition appears to be caused by two related things: 1. an overabundance of mites that we all carry on our skin and in our pores, and 2. a particular sensitivity to the bacteria in the mites waste products. Knowing this, it may be that gluten, or wheat, or some other food affects your skin in a way that either encourages reproduction of these mites, or discourages it. Things that discourage it would be helpful for your condition. Perhaps gluten or some other food (excess simple sugar and dairy are possible culprits) changes the acidity, oil production, or some other factor of your skin, and that, in turn, is what improves or worsens your condition. In Health, Suzanne Dixon (Author of No Nutritional Fear Mongering)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s